Directed by Nicolas Roeg and written by Paul Mayersberg, Thomas Jerome Newton is an alien who has come to Earth in search of water to save his home planet. Aided by lawyer Oliver Farnsworth, Thomas uses his knowledge of advanced technology to create profitable inventions. While developing a method to transport water, Thomas meets Mary-Lou, a quiet hotel clerk, and begins to fall in love with her. Starring: David Bowie, Rip Torn, Candy Clark, Tony Mascia, Buck Henry, Bernie Casey and Adrienne La Russa.
When it comes to The Man Who Fell to Earth there are really two sides to its tale, one strong and the other weak. The strong element being its visual, it has such a grand scale, an opulence to its sets, as well as terrific costume and makeup work. It’s a sight to behold, especially in 4K with the rich colours perfectly matching its extravagance. The cinematography from Anthony B. Richmond is terrific, it manages to capture the everyday in some moments, while moving far beyond it in others. Visually, Nicolas Roeg fills the film with energy and mystery, but unfortunately the writing can’t catch up.
Part of that problem is that the story itself isn’t particularly strong on its own, but it’s also because The Man Who Fell to Earth feels unfocused. There’s an unfortunate amount of time spent upon sex, which does make sense in the larger picture of its story about falling foul of excess and gluttony, and being made in the 1970s, but it’s unfortunately just not that interesting or seductively done. Particularly as some parts of it have not aged very well. Outside of that it has a frequent habit of meandering, and forgetting to establish some of the key points, like Thomas’ (David Bowie) origins and motivations, until surprisingly late in the film. Resulting in a rather slow, unsatisfying story.
It’s a shame as along with that visual, David Bowie gives a great performance, which is sadly limited by the writing. He potentially could have built such a big personality, one filled with curiosity and compassion but instead it feels muted for the most part. Whereas Rip Torn and Candy Clark bring through bigger personalities but they’re only able to do so much when they’re mostly pawns in this story, rather than able to truly influence it. It’s a strong ensemble, they just don’t have a creative enough tale to work with.
The Man Who Fell to Earth is visually fantastic, and it’s always a joy to watch David Bowie at work, especially when you have the opportunity to see him on the big screen. There was a lot of potential within this film, but not all of it comes to fruition. It’s unfortunately much stronger visually than thematically. There are some interesting layers exploring the gluttonous nature of human behaviour, especially when it comes to alcohol and television, but it feels entirely underexplored and that you’re having to dig more than you should to grasp the conversation it’s trying to have. It’s a tricky story to warm up to and for some, they still won’t get there before the credits roll.
