Written and directed by Johnny Russell, co-written by Archie Thomson, based on the true story of Joy Milne, following a Scottish scrub nurse whose life begins to unravel after she detects a strange, persistent smell during a routine operation. Convinced she has discovered an ability to detect a disease through scent, her concerns are dismissed by her husband, who is also the lead surgeon. But as her certainty grows and those around her refuse to listen, she puts her profession and her marriage on the line to fight for her credibility. Starring: Josie Walker, Cal MacAninch, Laura Rollins, Rob Jarvis and Jane Paul-Gets.
It’s hard to deny that this sort of discovery is miraculous, to be able to detect Parkinson’s disease through smell, and help countless people with early detection. So, it’s of no surprise that Johnny Russell and Archie Thomson wanted to capture this story on film. It’s one filled with a deep sadness but also triumph, it’s led by a sincere care and kindness. As well as capturing the age old tale of trusting your instincts when they’re telling you that something is wrong.
Russell’s direction in the earlier scenes as we figure out what’s truly going on with Nancy (Josie Walker) and this unknown smell, has a touch of mystery to it. He creates a curious atmosphere, that’s well matched by the solemn nature of the story. The cinematography from Max Brunner is excellent work, it’s compelling and captures the tone of A Scent. There’s a richness to the colouring, while also feeling earnest, particularly with such earthy tones and really leaning on that greyish blue hue for the hospital scenes. It all helps to build a touching atmosphere which is complemented very well by the subtle score from Adiescar Chase.
Although, the heart of A Scent really lies with Josie Walker’s performance, it’s understated, humble and compassionate. There’s an observant nature to it, embracing how her caregiver background makes her more aware of subtle signs and red flags, and taking a very gentle approach to discussing them. Walker gives Nancy an engaging warmth and dedication. While Cal MacAninch strongly portrays the reluctancy to accept such a wild theory, a sincere denial and a compelling vulnerability. Rob Jarvis is also a great addition, adding an extra dose of personality and capturing that all too common state of needing help, while not fully aware of it, until someone guides you in the right direction.
A Scent is a sad yet hopeful story, led by a terrific performance from Josie Walker, who brings such an effortless warmth. It’s very well shot, the cinematography does a wonderful job of matching the moving tone of the short. Johnny Russell’s direction has a great curious quality to it, while keeping things on a humble note. The writing balances the story of her discovery with exploring her marriage well, but it can ultimately fall into overly sentimental territory. The style softens itself a touch too much, missing a sharpness in its ending, but it’s a well made short.
FilmCarnage.com 